As a new filler arc downed on the Naruto Shippuden viewers, I
decided to rewatch it all over again, in order to remember how everything
started.
I embarked yet once again on an extremely
emotional journey, filled with tears, hope, love, nostalgic smiles, and an
overwhelming desire to be ackowledged.
Somewhere in between singing the openings
that ruled my childhood and crying over Naruto's determination to become
Hokage, I realised that the popular anime ( and one of my favourite things in
this entire universe) has some major, unfortunate flaws. The story remains a
life-changing, heart-warming, tearjerking experience, but, as a feminist and
aspiring writer myself, I just had to point these little things out.
Because they are not little at all.
Even though there are a lot of things to
say about this brilliant anime, I will only focus on character development, and
especially on female ones. A full on review may come somewhere in the near
future, but, for now, this post will only include my thoughts on this
particular issue.
While I do think that
one of the best things about Naruto is it's ability to make you believe in
yourself, I would have enjoyed it even more if it had at least 3 decent female
characters.
Bare with me on this one.
I'm gonna start off with Sakura, as she is
pretty much the central heroine. I feel like a lot of fans have a particular
problem with her, calling her "weak" and "useless" on a
daily basis, but I conceived this essay as to point out that Sakura is not the
only character that got completely destroyed
for the sake of an arc. I think that the anger everyone is feeling should not
be directed at the character itself, but at Masashi Kishimoto's dissapointing
inability to write honorable female characters. I was never a fan of her
myself, because, frankly, I just couldn't stand her. And the worst thing about
this is that she was supposed to be likeable.
She was supposed to be written as the main
heroine, not as a character everyone loved to hate. But things turned out
unexpected as she became this huge ball of annoyance from the very first
episodes, appearing as shallow, inconsiderate and borderline ignorant. While
Sasuke and Naruto were able to understand pain and develop enough power to save
the world, Sakura was always standing back with her little kunai. She has
always been painted as an irritating fangirl, rather than a real, serious
shinobi, only perpetuating the harmful idea that girls are not as good as boys
at...well, anything. She was clever, but not a good enough ninja, leader or
fighter, and when she finally gained some power it was obviously appropiate for
a woman- healing ninjutsu, because, you know, we are caretakers to the core.
I feel deeply sorry that the producers
felt the need to murder her character, as I am convinced that she had
tremendous potential. The Sasori arc was the only one in which her power was
actually valued, but everyone seemed to forget about her abilities afterwards
and only involve her in the story when she needed saving. Even during the war,
when team 7 reunited for the first time, she clearly stated that she won't fall
behind the other two again, promising to fight together, yet, minutes after an
emotional speech, she literally stand back as Sasuke and Naruto
attacked and fighted Obito with all they had.
That being said, Sakura is not useless,
but she is a painful stereotype, one that could have been avoided if only the
writer was a bit more careful.
On the other hand, Hinata was not even
developed that far, her only role in the plot consisting in obsessing
over Naruto. She was placed there as a colourless, undeveloped heroine, whose
relationship with Naruto was shoved down our throat even though it was merely
platonic. Her entire universe is Naruto, and her power is mediocre. She is here
to fix the protagonist, so he can go fix the world, as she herself would never
actually be qualified enough to do that. She is more of a plot point, solely created for
occasionally helping the protagonist up, rather than an actual character.
Tsunade was the one that gave me the
illusion she is a properly written female character for quite a while, until I
realised that she is supposed to be a very powerful shinobi, hell, a legendary
sannin, and still put her appearance first (because, well, that's all women
ever care about). While there is nothing wrong with wanting to be pretty,
Tsunade was not portrayed like that in order to show a personality
trait, but to appeal to the straight males that dominate the audience. And
while we focus on male character's power, intelligence, and strategic
abilities, a female character also has to be beautiful/sexy/desirable in order
to be relevant.
As a Hokage, she has to be rather
agressive in order to be taken seriously, and even though she has the same
superhuman strenght as Raikage (Bee's brother), she doesn't have any actual
muscles, because, you know, they would kind of oppose the hot kunoichi thing
that she has going on. And as the leader of the ninja village, her body is not
supposed to be appropiate for fighting as efficently as possible, but for
looking good enough for the male viewers, right?
Please notice the sarcasm, because that is
so, so wrong.
You simply can not convince me that she
would focus her chakra on mantaining her appearance, rather than on healing her
comarades, because I would just call bullshit on you. I know that you agree
with me, yet, if you really think about it, that's kind of what she does during
The Fourth War, when, after almost being killed by Madara, she only gets up the
moment her beauty is ressurected. Her looks "heal" first, but I would
dare to say that, had she focused that chakra on actual fighting, maybe she
would have managed to do more.
So why is a capable Hokage like herself
made to to such silly things? Why do female characters always have to be
somewhat attractive in order to be liked by the audience? Why do we never see
her actual (old) face?
Going on with my little essay, I would
also like to point out to you that an actual canon fact about the series is
that Ten Ten had less screen time that TonTon ( Tsunade's pig). So yeah, there
is that for you.
Rin was the ultimate usage of the annoying
trope called "women in refrigerator" which basically refers to the
producers' tendency of killing off female characters in order to give the
protagonist a reason to seek for revenge. People came up with this trope after
noticing a disturbing pattern: While male characters always die a significant,
heroic and meaningful death, female characters die in order
to justify a male character's
actions.
Think about it. Think about all the deaths
of female and male characters, and the difference between them. Minato, being
remembered as a great Hokage, the hero that saved the village from the big bad
tailed beast, while no one remembers or even acknowledges Kushina. Neji, Asuma,
Jiraya, Pain and Itachi dying in emotional ways, for the sake of the village or
the actual world, while the female characters don't even get the chance to
engage in exciting fights before being rescued as the damsels in distress they
are. Rin, being a kid that
gave her 12 year old life away in order to protect the village, yet
only being remembered as Obito's crush. Not a hero. Not
impressive. Just the reason we got a new villan.
Rin can also identify with yet another
overused trope, which some of you may know under the harrowing name of
"Manic pixie dream girl". Just as the trope requires, this 12
year old girl had no ambitions of her own, no likes, no dislikes, and no actual
goals. Unlike Sakura, Hinata, and other female characters, when hearing her
teammates talking about training more and getting stronger, she turns into some
sort of cheerleader that is only there to encourage Obito, with no intention of
becoming stronger on her own. Not once do we hear her stating her motivation to
do something for herself, or, frankly, to do anything else besides taking care
of Obito like some sort of babysitter and encouraging him whenever he feels
down. She is also a shinobi, but she doesn't care about improving her skills or
obtaining any qualifications. She only cares about buying gifts for Kakashi and
bringing Obito's homework.
Ten Ten had less screen time than a pig.
Ino also has fangirl tendencies, because,
apparently, crushes can go only one way and can only be felt by girls. You
know, the ones interested in unimportant matters like romance and marriage,
while boys focus on training and saving the world.
Karin is also very powerful, but we
wouldn't know that as she is only showing her skills when they benefit Sasuke.
Also, him trying to kill her did not improve her character ( as it would have
happened if she was a male) but merely turned her into a crazy person obsessed
with her tormentor. Funny enough, the scene actually managed to develop
Sasuke's character, showing us how cruel he has become and how much he has
changed. They destroyed her character as to give Sasuke 2 more personality
traits. They literally traded her sanity for the benefit of a male character's
story.
And Ten Ten had less screen time than a
pig.
Now, if you didn't understand why I wrote
all this by now, please allow me to enlighten you. I wanted to point out how the harmful stereotypes
that are already associated with women keep haunting us even in the wonderful
world of anime. I wanted
to point out how it is not Sakura who is useless and annoying, it is actually
the writer's fault that she came out that way UNINTENTIONALLY. I
wanted to emphasise how the media's depiction of a woman perpetuates the
damaging ideology that we are less than.
When we are, in fact,
so, so much more.
We are not caretakers and we are not here
for your entertainment. We are not the reason heroes and villans are born,
because we are heroes and villans and leaders and fighters and creators on
our own. We have our own
ambitions and our own desires and we can also be heroes. Our fictional
representations are made to appear victimized and disposable, meaningless in
both life and death.
Naruto is just an example. I did not
create this post in order to criticise the anime itself, as it is one of the
best stories I've ever came across, but just to share with you some things I
have noticed as I was rewatching it. It is also part of the painful society we
all live in, and it's philosophy stating the lack of meaning a woman holds is
reflected even in a show that used to be for kids. I grew up watching it, but I
wish that, as a little girl, I could identify with a female character that
actually held some relevance.
Dear writers, producers, and creators all
over the world, please deliver more accurate portaryals of women. Please, make
more decent female characters. And please, for the love of God, create heroines
that will make a girl feel like she could be anything, and not like her story is less important than that of a pig.
Niciun comentariu:
Trimiteți un comentariu